Hong Kong Property Co-Owner Risks Explained
Listen to the blog audio:
The following three situations are the most common risks in Hong Kong properties but are the most easily overlooked by buyers:
- Loss of contact with a co-owner
- Bankruptcy of a co-owner
- Divorce of a co-owner
All three directly affect whether the property can be sold, whether the mortgage can be renewed, whether the title can be transferred, and can even weaken the integrity of the property rights.
I. Co-owner Missing: Property Enters "Unmanageable" State
For any joint property, whether it is a joint tenancy or tenancy in common, actions such as selling, refinancing, or transferring ownership require the consent and signatures of all co-owners. When one of them goes missing, the following situations may arise:
1｜Property Cannot Be Sold
Without the signature of any co-owner, the property transfer process cannot proceed. The sale will be forced to terminate, and the seller may even be held liable to the buyer for delays.
2｜Mortgage Renewal or Refinancing Blocked
Banks must obtain signatures from all borrowers. If a co-owner cannot be contacted, refinancing cannot proceed, and the homeowner may be forced to continue paying a higher interest rate mortgage plan.
3｜Legal Remedies Are Complex and Time-Consuming
You may need to apply for:
- Court-appointed property manager
- Forced sale order
- Public notice to locate missing person
The above procedures are costly, time-consuming, and approval is not guaranteed. Therefore, missing co-owners represent one of the most challenging risks to property ownership.
II. Co-owner Bankruptcy: Property Rights Automatically Divided and Taken Over by the Official Receiver's Office
When one of the co-owners declares bankruptcy, significant and immediate legal changes occur to their rights in the property. According to bankruptcy law and case precedents, after a joint tenant (joint tenancy with right of survivorship) goes bankrupt, their share no longer exists as a joint tenancy but is automatically considered severed and converted into an independent share as a tenant in common. This share is then taken over and managed by the Official Receiver's Office (or trustee).
Below are the practical impacts of bankruptcy on the property:
1｜Bankrupt's Shares Become "Bankruptcy Assets" and Are Handled by the Official Receiver's Office
The bankrupt's named interests are no longer under their control, but are managed by the Official Receiver's Office as the bankruptcy trustee. The Official Receiver's Office will:
- Treat this share as debt repayment assets
- Dispose of it at the best market value as a priority
- Give primary consideration to protecting creditors' interests
This means the disposal method of the property is no longer decided by the family or other co-owners.
2｜Property Sale Arrangements Are Led by the Official Receiver's Office and May Not Align with the Wishes of Other Co-owners
Even if other co-owners wish to sell the property to resolve the issue, the Official Receiver's Office may not agree, as its decision criteria are:
- Whether it helps increase the value of the bankrupt assets
- Whether it benefits the creditors
- Whether there is sufficient reason to sell immediately
As a result, the property may remain in a "not convenient for sale" state for a long time.
3｜Mortgage arrangements may be forced to adjust, and may also trigger repossession risks
If the bankrupt is also a co-borrower:
- The bank can pursue other co-owners for the bankrupt's share of the repayments
- If other co-owners are unable to bear the burden, the bank has the right to take legal action
- In extreme cases, the bank may exercise the right to repossess the property
Bankruptcy can turn a previously stable repayment arrangement into one that is highly uncertain, and may also affect the ability of other co-owners to apply for mortgages or remortgages in the future.
III. Co-owner Divorce: Property Ownership Structure Determines Subsequent Handling Methods
Divorce involves property distribution, and the handling of real estate varies significantly depending on the type of ownership.
1｜Joint Tenancy Can Be Unilaterally Converted to Tenancy in Common
The law allows any co-owner to unilaterally "sever" a joint tenancy, converting the property to tenancy in common and equally dividing the shares between both parties. This action does not require the consent of the other party.
This means: The inheritance and interest arrangements under a joint tenancy can change immediately after a marriage breakdown.
2｜Property Distribution After Divorce is Determined by Family Court
Even if the deed states 50/50, the family court can redistribute the property based on factors such as contribution ratio, length of marriage, and childcare responsibilities. The proportion on the title deed does not necessarily equal the final legal distribution.
3｜When No Agreement is Reached, the Property May Be Unsellable or Unrefinanceable for a Long Time
Divorce negotiations often take many years. During this period, the property may become stagnant due to disagreements between both parties:
- Cannot refinance
- Cannot sell
- Cannot change the ownership structure
- May affect tax arrangements when purchasing a new property
In divorce cases, the property is often one of the most difficult parts to handle.
Four, Principles to Consider When Choosing Co-Owners
Long-term joint tenancy is more suitable:
- Married couples
- Partners
- Parties with complete trust who wish for automatic inheritance, aiming to simplify inheritance and reduce disputes.
Co-ownership with Separate Rights is More Suitable:
- Parents and children
- Siblings
- Investors
- Combinations that require clear allocation of rights and interests This arrangement better maintains fairness and avoids unnecessary family conflicts.
What often causes a property to become frozen is not the deed itself, but changes among co-owners. Whether it's loss of contact, bankruptcy, or divorce, any of these can render a property unsellable, unmortgageable, or untransferable overnight. Therefore, when deciding on co-owners, besides trust, it's essential to consider potential legal and financial risks.
